Deborah HERBST (c. 1952- )
1 Deborah Kay HERBST1,2,3 (c. 1952- ) [14310]. Born c. 1952.3 Marr Clay Emerson CARNES 7 May 1977, Monticello, OH.2
2 Lowell B. HERBST4,5,6,7 (1913-1982) [14303]. Born 15 Nov 1913, OH.6,8 Marr Wanda Wonetta MCCASLIN 11 Feb 1939.5 Died 26 Dec 1982, Lima, OH.8,9
3 Wanda Wonetta MCCASLIN4,5,6,10,11,12,13 (1917-1998) [14290]. Born 24 Apr 1917, OH.6,10,11,12,13 Died 7 Nov 1998, Lima, OH.14
6 Earl Lawrence MCCASLIN10,11,12,15,16 (1892-1965) [14288]. Born 15 Mar 1892, Arkansas City, KS.16 Marr Sarah Estella BATTLES Dec 1914.4,10 Died 17 Dec 1965.17 Cause: Farm tractor accident. Buried Memorial Park Cemetery, Lima, OH.17
The death report of Earl McCaslin in the Lima News reports that he was born March 13, 1892 although his WWI registration clearly says March 15. We also have confusion over the marriage date of Earl and Estella. The 1930 census seemed to show 1916 while the article on their 50th anniversary seemed to indicate December 1914. This article says December 16, 1914.
7 Sarah Estella BATTLES10,11,12,15,18,19 (1895-1969) [14286]. Born 18 May 1895, Allen County, OH.12,18,19 Died 26 Apr 1969, Lima, OH.19 Buried Memorial Park Cemetery, Lima, OH.19
14 Clarence BATTLES18,20 (1872- ) [14173]. Born Jun 1872, OH.18 Marr Flora C. OSMON 3 Jul 1894.21
15 Flora C. OSMON10,11,18,20,22 (1876-1945) [14171]. Born Jan 1876, OH.18 Died 24 Oct 1945, Painesville, OH.15
Sources
| 1 | "United States Obituary Collection for Terry Lee McCaslin". |
| 2 | "Wedding announcement of Deborah Kay Herbst and Clay Emerson Carnes in the Lima News, June 3, 1977". |
| 3 | "Ohio Marriage Index, 1970, 1972-2007". |
| 4 | "50th Anniversary announcement of Mr. and Mrs. E.L. McCaslin in the Lima News, December 13, 1964". |
| 5 | "Marriage announcement of Woneta McCaslin and Lowell Herbst in the Lima News, February 12, 1939". |
| 6 | "1940 OH, Allen, Lima census". |
| 7 | "Article on Robert B. Herbst in the Lima News, April 26, 1971". |
| 8 | "Social Security Death Index". |
| 9 | "Ohio Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-2007". |
| 10 | "1920 OH, Allen, Lima census". |
| 11 | "1930 OH, Allen, Shawnee census". |
| 12 | "1940 OH, Allen, Shawnee census". |
| 13 | "Birthday list showing Wand Woneta McCaslin in the Lima News, April 24, 1930". |
| 14 | "Ohio Deaths, 1908-1932, 1938-1944, and 1958-2002". |
| 15 | "Obituary of Flora C. Battles in the Lima News, October 25, 1945". |
| 16 | "WWI Selective Service registration card". |
| 17 | "Death report of Earl McCaslin in the Lima News, December 18, 1965". |
| 18 | "1900 OH, Allen, Bath census". |
| 19 | "Obituary of Sarah Estella McCaslin in the Lima News, April 28, 1969". |
| 20 | "Obituary of Sara Louise Partello in the Times Democrat, Lima, OH, March 13, 1900". |
| 21 | "Notice of divorce sought by Flora A. Battles from Clarence Battles in the Lima News, Feb. 28, 1923". |
| 22 | "1880 OH, Allen, Bath census". |
